We're a Baker Tilly network member
Learn more
Back to top
EVPs for NFPs: the missing piece of the retention puzzle?
Article

EVPs for NFPs: the missing piece of the retention puzzle?

Key findings: 

  • Creating a strong Employee Value Proposition (EVP) should be a core focus for an organisation’s leaders  
  • People aren’t as interested in climbing a ’career ladder’, instead opting to move around a ‘career lattice’ that offers a wide breadth of experiences 
  • Building a strong EVP starts with understanding and listening to your people 

Workplaces have been tested over the last four years. From a swift transition to working from home to inflation that’s seen salaries increase rapidly, the war for talent continues as candidates look for companies that provide the trust and flexibility they’ve become accustomed to. And with many not-for-profit (NFP) organisations not in a position to compete by creating attractive salary packages, an organisation needs other ways to attract and retain the right talent. It’s why creating a strong EVP should be a core focus for leaders today.  

A strong EVP fosters a better workplace culture and sets the foundations to attract and retain talent, which is especially important in a tight labour market. And for businesses in the NFP space, the importance of care, both for your community and your people should underpin your strategy. This article outlines how to create a strong EVP and why it’s crucial for companies of all sizes, industries and stages of growth. 

Why is having a strong EVP important?

The Pitcher Partners Business Radar Report 2022 found that up to 52% of middle-market businesses have seen an increase in staff turnover. Further, 49% of respondents have found it challenging to attract or retain the right people. Businesses, regardless of maturity or industry are experiencing these challenges.  Respondents included NFP business leaders, so if you are experiencing increased turnover or difficulty attracting and retaining talent, you’re not alone. Similarly, if people within your business have shifted focus from climbing the ‘career ladder’ to instead opting to move around a ‘career lattice’ to gain a breadth of experiences, this is common too. 

Developing a strong EVP is a crucial part of addressing how people’s approach to work has changed, and the resourcing challenges facing NFP businesses. Most NFP’s are the perfect size to provide a personal career experience and the learning and development opportunities people need to remain engaged. They are in a good position to differentiate themselves from bigger organisations by strengthening their EVPs. A strong EVP will help your business to: 

  • attract talent at every level 
  • retain the best employees 
  • build a reputation for being ‘the’ place to work in the sector 
  • showcase and strengthen your brand 
  • demonstrate how you deliver on key values

For NFP’s, it’s also an opportunity to ‘walk the walk’ as values-driven organisations. Creating an EVP provides a tangible platform to show your people that you care. It also demonstrates to those considering a role that you are serious about your people and culture.  A strong EVP can be an enticing hook that engages a potential hire to work with you over another organisation, especially if you aren’t in a position to compete when it comes to remuneration or other resource-driven benefits. 

For many people, choosing to work as part of an NFP is often driven by values alignment, a desire for purpose-driven work or community impact. It is generally accepted that NFP organisations aren’t in a position to attract staff through higher remuneration. While this can sometimes be a bit of an ‘elephant in the room’, you can leverage a strong EVP to your advantage,  taking an opportunity to communicate openly with your people about how you remunerate and the reasons for any limitations,  and highlight the other value and benefits for staff. An EVP is also a great tool to identify if people may not be the best fit, which can be a financial benefit when you consider that it costs an average  $21,078 to attract, hire and train new staff members. 

Start by engaging with your people

To establish or evolve your EVP, you need to engage with your people. Key things that the organisation needs to understand include: 

  • why they chose to join the company 
  • why people enjoy coming to work 
  • what has changed about their experience with the company since they started 
  • what could be improved 
  • what career outcomes people are looking for 

How you engage with your people to understand the points above will look different for each entity, depending on the size of the organisation and its culture. It doesn’t have to take up a large amount of time or resources, but can be tailored to what will work best for you and your needs. For smaller NFP’s, or those that work with limited resourcing, it is a great opportunity to engage one-on-one with people to understand their career aspirations – giving you more targeted engagement and relevant actions to take. It’s also important to create an environment and culture where people can be candid about what’s working and what needs improvement. Anonymous surveys with a combination of multiple choice or rating scale questions and free text answers will provide a good mix of quantitative and qualitative data to work from. 

Build the five core elements of a strong EVP

Once you have feedback from your people, the business needs to work collaboratively to build out the five core elements of a strong EVP. These elements are: 

  1. Unique: Customise your EVP to your business. 
  2. Compelling: Think about how the business will stand out from competitors. 
  3. Relevant: Get feedback to ensure your EVP addresses what is valuable to your people. 
  4. Evolve: Your EVP must be fluid and evolve with your business, the market and your people. 
  5. Marketing: Market your EVP internally and externally. 

Think about how the business will stand out in the market through its EVP. Will the business update its flexible work policy in response to demand and the transition people have made to hybrid working? You also need to consider how to differentiate the organisation in the market. Use feedback from your people and scan the market to collaboratively create an EVP that’s compelling to everyone in your organisation. 

Continually market and evolve your EVP

A strong EVP is dynamic, evolving with the market and your people. The process of creating or evolving your EVP shouldn’t be a one-off project. Instead, it should establish a process of gathering regular feedback to understand your people and their priorities and aspirations. Further, your EVP will gain more traction if building and evolving it is a collaborative process, and it is marketed effectively. You may consider the following channels to market your EVP: 

  • Internal: News bulletins, internal screens in communal office areas, on the company’s intranet, and in team meetings presented by your leaders. 
  • External: On social media, job advertisements and to potential candidates in the recruitment and selection process. 

Don’t make your EVP a guessing game; engage now to remain competitive

Strengthening your EVP provides an excellent opportunity to engage with your people. It will help you understand what is and isn’t working for your people and provide the foundations to differentiate the company in the market. And when you’re not able to leverage resources to compete for talent, an EVP is the best tool to showcase values alignment, purpose-driven work and other benefits that may appeal to your ideal hires. The key to differentiation in the market is genuine engagement and collaboration with your people. Building your EVP from this place will provide the roadmap to continually improve and update it as the market changes. 

 

This content is general commentary only and does not constitute advice. Before making any decision or taking any action in relation to the content, you should consult your professional advisor. To the maximum extent permitted by law, neither Pitcher Partners or its affiliated entities, nor any of our employees will be liable for any loss, damage, liability or claim whatsoever suffered or incurred arising directly or indirectly out of the use or reliance on the material contained in this content. Pitcher Partners is an association of independent firms. Pitcher Partners is a member of the global network of Baker Tilly International Limited, the members of which are separate and independent legal entities. Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.

Pitcher Partners insights

Get the latest Pitcher Partners updates direct to your inbox

Thank you for you interest

How can we help you?

Business or personal advice
General information
Career information
Media enquiries
Contact expert
Become a member
Specialist query
Please provide as much detail to ensure appropriate allocation of your query
Please highlight a realistic time frame that will enable us to provide advice within a suitable and timely manner. Please note given conflicting demands with our senior personnel, we will endeavour to respond to you within the nominated time frame. If you require an urgent response, please contact us on 03 8610 5477.
CPN Enquiry
Business Radar 2024
Dealmakers 2024
Tax Facts 2024-25
Search by industry